ToolNavs Find Useful AI Tools
Submit Sign in
Back to AI information
Over 540 Google Workers Sign a Petition: Schools Want Search Without the AI

Over 540 Google Workers Sign a Petition: Schools Want Search Without the AI

AI information • Admin • • 13 views

On November 19, Bloomberg reported that more than 540 Google employees and contractors signed a petition asking the company to let schools keep using Google Search without its AI features. Organized by the Alphabet Workers Union and addressed to CEO Sundar Pichai, Search chief Elizabeth Reid, and education chief Chris Phillips, the petition takes aim at Google's bundling of Search and AI: no AI, no Search.

What the fight is about

The dispute traces back to Google's November 3 decision: starting in early 2027, Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom, and Search will be switched off by default for K-12 student accounts, with administrators turning each one on individually. That sounds like a choice — but the catch is in the second half: a school that wants to keep Search has to accept the version with AI features built in, because AI Overviews and AI Mode cannot be switched off. Google's explanation is that Search and AI are too deeply integrated to separate. The petition's answer: educators should decide how and when AI enters the classroom; cutting off Search for schools that do not want AI will not persuade users — it will more likely push them to shut out Google products altogether.

Pressure is closing in, from Congress to school districts

This is not an isolated protest. Senator Edward J. Markey wrote to Pichai on November 9, demanding a commitment to decouple the products by November 30, along with research on safety and learning effects; his letter cited a lawsuit in which a 13-year-old shared suicidal thoughts with Gemini through Search on a school-issued Chromebook, even though the school had already blocked the chatbot's standalone app and website. The New York City Council wrote to Google on November 12, asking for a written reply by November 19. Meanwhile, the school districts of New York City, Los Angeles, and Chicago are all considering switching to another search engine; Los Angeles has already disabled AI Overviews for students, and its chief information officer said changing the default search engine could be done overnight.

Has Google budged?

Google's response so far goes only halfway: schools can toggle Search, Gemini, and Gemini Notebook separately — but that does not answer the core question of whether the AI features built into Search itself can be switched off independently. Two dates are worth watching: November 30 is Markey's deadline for an answer, and whether the three big districts actually switch search engines will depend on whether Google offers a new plan before then. For schools, the real question is not "AI or no AI" — it is "can we choose Search alone?"

Recommended Tools

More